All students and the therapists who are treating patients with stroke must have thought or heard this kind of question in their practice.
What is the therapeutic management of frontal lobe bleed/infarction?
What is the therapeutic management of occipital bleed /infarction?
What is the therapeutic management of parietal bleed /infarction?
What is the therapeutic management of thalamic bleed?
Instead of answering these questions, we need to ask different questions
What are the sign & symptoms of these patients? What are the physical & perceptual impairments of patients?
What are the activity the patient is able to do and not able to do?
What impairments are limiting the activity? What are the contextual factors & personal and environmental factors are restricting his participation?
Neurologist does the medical or neurological diagnosis of patient’s i. e. Stroke due to infarction or bleed. Bleed or infraction internal capsule, thalamus, basal ganglion, MCA territory etc. This different level of injury and severity will helps us in finding out the prognosis and planning of treatment according to level of lesion and severity of it.
But for us as a physiotherapist we need to look at the movement dysfunction. We need to find the physiotherapeutic diagnosis of movement dysfunction. Such as hemiplegia, henianesthesia, cognitive and perceptual disorders, unilateral neglect, heminomus hemianopia, shoulder dislocation, genu recurvatum, hemiplegic hand, claw hand, fixed flexion deformity,
“Stoke is Medical diagnosis, Hemilplegia is a Physical diagnosis ….!”
We treat hemiplegia neurologist treats stroke.
We need to keep in mind that we as therapists don’t treat the cause of the stroke like the medical management. We don’t plan treatment directly with the causative factors of the stroke.
We treat physical & functional dysfunction – “MOVEMENT DYSFUNCTION”.
We plan our management according to:-
Every patient basic physical functional demands from life are: -
To get the right answer for the management you need to ask the right question….!
If you ask a right question you will get the right answer for it.
Your main objective should be changing the participation and activity limitation in community (based on ICF model).
“Our treatment should bring some change in his life and not in the impairment…!”
What is the therapeutic management of frontal lobe bleed/infarction?
What is the therapeutic management of occipital bleed /infarction?
What is the therapeutic management of parietal bleed /infarction?
What is the therapeutic management of thalamic bleed?
Instead of answering these questions, we need to ask different questions
What are the sign & symptoms of these patients? What are the physical & perceptual impairments of patients?
What are the activity the patient is able to do and not able to do?
What impairments are limiting the activity? What are the contextual factors & personal and environmental factors are restricting his participation?
Neurologist does the medical or neurological diagnosis of patient’s i. e. Stroke due to infarction or bleed. Bleed or infraction internal capsule, thalamus, basal ganglion, MCA territory etc. This different level of injury and severity will helps us in finding out the prognosis and planning of treatment according to level of lesion and severity of it.
But for us as a physiotherapist we need to look at the movement dysfunction. We need to find the physiotherapeutic diagnosis of movement dysfunction. Such as hemiplegia, henianesthesia, cognitive and perceptual disorders, unilateral neglect, heminomus hemianopia, shoulder dislocation, genu recurvatum, hemiplegic hand, claw hand, fixed flexion deformity,
“Stoke is Medical diagnosis, Hemilplegia is a Physical diagnosis ….!”
We treat hemiplegia neurologist treats stroke.
We need to keep in mind that we as therapists don’t treat the cause of the stroke like the medical management. We don’t plan treatment directly with the causative factors of the stroke.
We treat physical & functional dysfunction – “MOVEMENT DYSFUNCTION”.
We plan our management according to:-
- What are activities limitations?
- What impairments (signs and symptoms) of patients causing activity limitation
- What is the need of the patients according to their lifestyle, age and occupational demands (personal & environmental factors, contextual factors)?
Every patient basic physical functional demands from life are: -
- Bed mobility- rolling supine to sit, bed side sitting etc
- Toilet training
- Transfers from bed to chair or toilet transfers
- Sit to stand
- Standing with or without assistive devices
- Walking with or without assistive devices
- Upper limb function for hands skills & manipulations
- Activities of daily living (ADL) & Instrumental Activities of daily living (IADL)- dressing, feeding, brushing, combing, reading writing & bathing etc
- Indoor and outdoor ambulation with or without assistive devices
- Stair climbing
To get the right answer for the management you need to ask the right question….!
If you ask a right question you will get the right answer for it.
Your main objective should be changing the participation and activity limitation in community (based on ICF model).
“Our treatment should bring some change in his life and not in the impairment…!”
This is where a neurologist should give a damage diagnosis as part of the ET prescription. Because if the therapist doesn't know where the damage is or what kind they really have no clue on what needs to be done. For example, A stroke patient presents with foot drop. Why does the patient have foot drop? Is it because the control of dorsiflexion is in the penumbra in the motor cortex and thus relatively easily recoverable just by exercise? Or is it in the dead brain area in the motor cortex? Or is it in the penumbra in the pre-motor cortex? Or is it in the dead brain area in the pre-motor cortex? Or is it in the penumbra in the executive control area? Or is it in the dead brain area in the executive control area? I would think that the therapies given would be different in the penumbra ones vs. the dead brain areas. Or do you just throw up your hands and tell the patient, 'All strokes are different, all stroke recoveries are different'?
ReplyDeleteYou really need to know what the damage is if you ever expect to fix it. I know since I am just a stroke survivor you can just dismiss me if you want to, but I will be proven correct.
dear oc1dean, Thanks for your comment. i do agree with your thoughts.
ReplyDelete